I'M TORN BETWEEN IDEAS

I wanted to check with my Epic Questers on what you guys would prefer for the story this year! I had one original idea that might be difficult to pull off, and then another... slightly more humorous one. You guys are the ones who will be participating, so I think you deserve a say!

The humorous idea - that I will have loads of fun with and will most definitely be enjoyable for most everybody:
A Harry Potter satire. Imagine, if you will... Headmaster Bumblebore. The four houses: Hero, Villain, Sidekick, and Civilian. An immortal evil by the name of Moldywart. Pursue your magical education at Swinetoots School of Slacking Safety (also known as Swinetoots Academy of Student Endangerment) and participate in iconic events such as the Teen Angst Ball, Plot Twist Tournament, and annual Supervillain Showdown - all while navigating the throughly predictable terrain of your classic coming-of-age tale.

The original idea - without giving too much away:
Set in a grand but isolated estate in the Scottish highlands. Late 1800s. Murder mystery. Magic (maybe). I have never written a mystery before so.. this one's a risk xD But it will include a colorful cast of NPCs - rather like the original Epic Quest. And one of you may or may not be the murderer!

So - which experience would you prefer? Lemme know!

Either way, the Epic Quest will return on Feb. 20th!

Bump!

I came back after Epic Quest started but I'm chipping in an opinion anyway since I want to partake this year! The Scottish idea is the one I'm liking the most!

original idea! 

Murder mystery !

-evil laugh- 

Excited to participate this year!

I also like the Scottish highlands mystery idea. 

My vote is for the murder mystery one but can we talk about 'teen angst ball' lmao

I also vote for the murder mystery idea!

I also vote for the murder mystery idea! I loveeeeee solving mysterys!

i think your murder mystery wins?!

I like both ideas!

-isn't helpful-

I was also leaning more towards the original idea as I'm really not a Harry Potter fan myself.

Can we have both? xD

Failing that, Scottish magicky murder mystery!

The HP one would be super fun, but I'm happy to participate in any type of quest! :D

I like the murder mystery idea